The first season of Celebrity Traitors concluded with comedian Alan Carr secretly playing a Traitor and winning £87,500 for charity, leaving audiences eager for more. With the show confirmed as a major success, speculation has immediately turned to which famous faces might appear in a potential second season.
Top Fan Picks for the Roundtable
Metro readers have been sharing their dream contestants, with several standout names emerging. Leading the pack is beloved comedian Bob Mortimer. The 66-year-old, known for his work with Vic Reeves and on shows like Taskmaster and Would I Lie to You?, is seen as a perfect fit. His unique storytelling ability and popularity could make him a formidable player. As one fan, Suzy, noted on Facebook, ‘It has to be Bob Mortimer, he can convince people that Chris Rea put an egg in his bath and he’d be hilarious.’
Another highly requested star is Ruth Jones, the 59-year-old Welsh actress and writer famed for her role as Nessa in Gavin & Stacey. Her experience on panel shows like Would I Lie to You? suggests she could hold her own in the tense roundtable discussions.
More Comedy Heavyweights and Reality Stars
Fans are also keen to see Greg Davies, the host of Taskmaster, switch roles and become a contestant. This would put him under the watchful eye of host Claudia Winkleman, creating a fascinating dynamic. Similarly, comedy legend Kathy Burke is a popular choice. The 61-year-old BAFTA-nominated star has extensive panel show experience and even hosts a podcast about death, making her well-acquainted with the show's darker themes.
The list extends to other well-known personalities, including Alison Hammond, whose history on reality TV from Big Brother to Strictly Come Dancing makes her a seasoned competitor. Drag artist La Voix, currently competing on Strictly Come Dancing 2025, is another fan favourite, praised for her humour and resilience.
Honourable Mentions and Fan Buzz
A host of other celebrities were put forward by readers, creating an exciting longlist of potential contestants. Notable honourable mentions include Bradley Walsh, Helen Mirren, Graham Norton, Sandi Toksvig, Gary Lineker, Dawn French, John Bishop, Jennifer Saunders, Rylan Clark, Vicky Pattison, Mark Labbett, and Alex Brooker.
Comedian James Acaster also features on many wishlists. Known for his sometimes-disastrous appearances on shows like Celebrity Bake Off and Celebrity Mastermind, his potential for creating memorable television moments is significant. His co-host on the podcast Off Menu, Ed Gamble, already presents the official Traitors aftershow, Uncloaked, adding another layer of connection.
While the BBC has yet to officially confirm a second celebrity season, the overwhelming fan response and the success of the first season make its return highly likely. The civilian version of The Traitors season 4 is scheduled for early 2026, building anticipation for the franchise's future.
