Reality TV star Maura Higgins has become an instant fan favourite on the latest season of The Traitors US after a fiery on-screen confrontation with actor Michael Rapaport, whom she branded 'insufferable'.
A Heated Exchange in the Castle
The clash unfolded during the show's third episode, which aired on January 12, 2026. The 35-year-old former Love Island contestant, known for her no-nonsense attitude, immediately picked up on Rapaport's choice of words during a discussion about eliminated players.
When the 55-year-old actor, best known for playing Phoebe's boyfriend Gary on Friends, used the phrase 'we got rid of', Higgins pounced. 'Why did you say, "we got rid of"? Does that mean you're a Traitor?' she demanded.
Rapaport attempted to defend himself, stating, 'Let me tell you something, Maura. I'm as faithful as a faithful.' Undeterred, Higgins pressed him again on his use of 'we', leading Rapaport to begin explaining, 'I've said a lot of things...' before Higgins sharply interrupted with, 'Maybe just stop talking.'
Viewers Crown Maura the People's Champion
The moment sparked a wave of support for Higgins on social media, with viewers praising her for standing up to the Hollywood veteran. One fan, @bbninjass, wrote: 'Oh Maura had him stuttering, gagged, and scared #TheTraitorsUS.'
Another, @queensofbravo, declared: 'It was at this moment that Maura Higgins spoke for all of us... Maura being unafraid and standing up to Michael is so far my favoritest part of the new season.' The sentiment was echoed widely, with @IsntDaveOne calling Higgins 'the breakout star this season.'
Many viewers agreed with Higgins's assessment, with @graciejones730 simply stating that Rapaport 'is insufferable.'
Controversial Casting and Stellar Line-Up
Rapaport's inclusion in the star-studded cast had already proven controversial prior to the season's launch due to his past legal issues and contentious online commentary. In 1997, he was arrested and pleaded guilty to harassing his ex-girlfriend, actress Lili Taylor, resulting in a protection order.
Hosted by Alan Cumming, the fourth season of the hit reality competition features a glittering array of celebrities from across the entertainment spectrum. The full roster of contestants includes:
- Yamil “Yam Yam” Arocho (Survivor)
- Candiace Dillard Bassett (The Real Housewives of Potomac)
- Donna Kelce, Travis Kelce's mother
- Lisa Rinna (The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills)
- Porsha Williams (The Real Housewives of Atlanta)
- Johnny Weir (Olympic Figure Skater)
- And many more.
Maura Higgins first found fame in the UK on series five of Love Island in 2019, where she was involved in a notable love triangle with Tommy Fury and Molly-Mae Hague. She successfully transitioned to US television in 2023, becoming the social media presenter for Love Island USA and later the host of Love Island USA: Aftersun in 2024.
As the deception and drama continue to unfold on The Traitors US, available to stream on Peacock, Higgins's fearless confrontation has undoubtedly cemented her position as a central figure to watch this season.
