Defence Review Co-Author Condemns 'Bizarre' Lack of Urgency in UK War Planning
Fiona Hill, a co-author of Britain's strategic defence review and former White House chief adviser on Russia, has joined criticism of Prime Minister Keir Starmer's leadership on military policy, describing a 'bizarre' lack of urgency in defence planning. Her comments echo those of her co-author, George Robertson, a peer and former Nato head, who has accused the government of 'corrosive complacency' in failing to detail its 10-year defence spending plans since the review's publication last June.
Robertson's Blunt Critique and Treasury 'Vandalism'
In a speech in Salisbury, Wiltshire, Robertson elaborated on his concerns, blaming non-military experts in the Treasury for what he termed 'vandalism' in defence budgeting. He warned that 'we cannot defend Britain with an ever-expanding welfare budget' and disclosed a discussion with Defence Secretary John Healey, who he said was 'extremely angry' with his public intervention. Robertson emphasised, 'I believe my country is in danger,' criticising the government's delay in providing spending details as inexplicable.
Political Backlash and Labour's Electoral Concerns
The suggestion that public spending cuts might fund defence has sparked backlash within Labour. Diane Abbott, a Labour MP, accused Robertson of putting 'guns before butter,' arguing that such moves could cost Labour votes to the Greens. She stated, 'People are going to start to wonder why they are voting Labour in the first place,' highlighting tensions over welfare versus defence priorities.
Hill's Warning on Urgency and Strategic Risks
Speaking to the Guardian, Hill reinforced Robertson's points, noting a lack of resolute leadership driven by political worries. She said, 'What George is saying, very bluntly, is there is basically a lack of resolute leadership on this.' Hill warned of risks, citing events in the Gulf and potential threats to UK landmarks like the Shard. She also highlighted economic consequences, with British defence companies losing orders and investors turning to the US due to government inaction.
Broader Defence Concerns and Calls for Action
General Richard Barrons, another co-author, told the BBC that there is an 'enormous gap' between needed security levels and current capabilities, noting the Royal Navy and Royal Air Force are 'undernourished.' Former Defence Secretary John Hutton urged Chancellor Rachel Reeves to borrow more for defence, similar to Germany, warning the UK has 18 months to deter Russian aggression. Tan Dhesi, chair of the Commons defence select committee, criticised Treasury ministers for avoiding accountability and echoed Robertson's concerns.
Government Response and Defence Spending Claims
A government spokesperson defended the strategic defence review, stating it is 'backed by the largest sustained increase in defence spending since the cold war,' with over £270bn invested across this parliament. However, critics argue that without detailed plans, this rhetoric lacks substance in addressing urgent security needs.
