Judge Advises Caution Over Barron Trump's Account in London Assault Trial
A judge has instructed jurors to approach Barron Trump's description of his friend's alleged attack in London with significant caution, warning that it may be biased due to their close friendship. The guidance came during a trial at Snaresbrook Crown Court, where Matvei Rumiantsev faces multiple serious charges.
Details of the Alleged Incident and Barron Trump's Involvement
Barron Trump, the 19-year-old son of US President Donald Trump, contacted UK police after reportedly witnessing his friend being assaulted during a video call on January 18, 2025. According to court proceedings, he informed a City of London Police operator that he had received a call from a girl who was getting beat up. Prosecutors allege that Rumiantsev, a 22-year-old Russian citizen residing in Canary Wharf, was motivated by jealousy over the woman's friendship with Trump.
Legal Directions from Mr Justice Bennathan KC
In his legal directions to the jury, Mr Justice Bennathan KC emphasised that Barron Trump did not give evidence under oath and was not subject to cross-examination. He highlighted that, had Trump testified, he could have been questioned about the clarity of his view during the incident and whether his perception was influenced by his friendship with the complainant.
The judge explained that while hearsay evidence is admissible, jurors must exercise care as it lacks the scrutiny of courtroom questioning. He advised them to consider potential mistakes or bias and avoid convicting the defendant primarily based on this account.
Prosecution's Case and Defendant's Response
Prosecutor Serena Gates argued in her closing statement that Rumiantsev's jealousy stemmed from the woman's association with Trump, possibly due to his public profile. The court heard that the alleged assault occurred after Rumiantsev and the woman had been drinking together on the evening of January 17, 2025.
Rumiantsev, who denies all charges including assault, actual bodily harm, intentional strangulation, perverting the course of justice, and two counts of rape, testified under cross-examination. He admitted to feeling unhappy about the woman's interactions with Trump, stating she was leading him on, but denied losing his temper due to jealousy.
Ongoing Trial and Broader Context
The trial continues, with Rumiantsev facing one count of rape between January 17 and 18, 2025, and another between November 1 and 30, 2024. The case has drawn attention due to the involvement of a prominent political family and the serious nature of the allegations.
This incident underscores the complexities of hearsay evidence in legal proceedings and the challenges jurors face in evaluating accounts from individuals with personal connections to the parties involved.
