Borthwick's Conservative Approach Threatens England's Future
Steve Borthwick faces a critical juncture as England's head coach, with his position under severe scrutiny following a disappointing Six Nations campaign. The Rugby Football Union's strategic plan, released in January, clearly states that England must not only win but do so in a manner that inspires future generations. Currently, Borthwick is failing on both fronts, with the team's lackluster performances drawing widespread criticism.
The Dual Crisis of Image and Imagination
Borthwick has identified discipline, profligacy, and injuries as key issues behind England's struggles. However, the core problems are twofold: image and imagination. England have developed a reputation as a dull, kicking-focused side, while their attack lacks the creativity and flair needed to compete at the highest level. This perception issue is compounded by Borthwick's conservative coaching style, which has seen him double down on restrictive tactics rather than liberating the team's potential.
Comparisons to the 2018 Six Nations are telling. Back then, Eddie Jones saved his job by turning to Danny Cipriani in a decisive moment. Borthwick, who was an assistant coach during that period, must now consider a similar gamble with Marcus Smith to avoid the same fate.
Marcus Smith's Diminished Role and Untapped Potential
Marcus Smith, set to earn his 50th cap against France, has seen his influence wane dramatically. Once a central figure in memorable victories, such as his match-winning drop goal against Ireland in 2024, Smith has been relegated to a peripheral role, playing just six minutes off the bench in the recent defeat to Italy. Despite being a fan favorite and a marketing asset for the RFU, Borthwick appears reluctant to fully trust him.
Smith's ability to inject excitement and unpredictability into England's attack could be the key to reversing the team's fortunes. Learning to trust and utilize Smith's talents might not only improve results but also help Borthwick secure his position ahead of the upcoming Nations Championship and the 2027 World Cup.
Empowering Attack Coach Lee Blackett
Another critical issue is the limited influence of attack coach Lee Blackett. Reports suggest that Blackett is given as little as five minutes in some training sessions to work on attacking strategies, which explains England's inefficiency in the opposition 22. Ben Spencer, the Bath captain, struggled to explain why Blackett's successful methods at club level have not translated to the international stage.
Borthwick must empower Blackett to implement his ideas more effectively. Giving him greater control over the attack could unlock the creativity that has been sorely lacking throughout the tournament.
The Stakes for Borthwick and the RFU
RFU CEO Bill Sweeney has effectively backed Borthwick until the summer, but a heavy defeat against France could force earlier action. With the Nations Championship on the horizon, Sweeney faces a dilemma: stick with Borthwick through the autumn fixtures or make a change to avoid toxicity at Twickenham. The success of the Nations Championship, which Sweeney views as a flagship project, depends on maintaining positive momentum and fan engagement.
Ultimately, Borthwick's survival may hinge on his willingness to embrace change. By trusting Marcus Smith and empowering Lee Blackett, he can address England's image and imagination problems, potentially saving his job and restoring hope to a disillusioned fanbase.
